Monday, August 03, 2009

Goodbye 3.5e

I never played D&D or B/X. I started playing AD&D 1e, then switched to AD&D 2e, then to 3e, then to 3.5e, always thinking that the new rules set was better than the prevoius one without giving it much thought, but no more. I now DM three 3.5e campaigns all set in the World of Greyhawk; one ongoing (Expedition to the Ruins of Greyhawk) and two other "on hold" (a long term one that we left in the middle of Maure Castle from Dungeon magazines - heathens! - and a homebrew one).

With time I've realized that allowing the use of books like the "Complete" or the PHB2 was a mistake. I should have known better that with the three core books was more than enough. What was done in the eagerness of adding flavor to the game, in the end became a cumbersome corset for me. I don't need more rules, spells, feats or classes to do what I intended to.

So then it's decided, once we've finished EttRoG I plan to go back to the roots, back to 1e, or B/X, or some of the OSR rules set like Swords&Wizardry or Labyrinth Lord.

3 comments:

  1. Sounds familiar - that's essentially why I abandoned 3.x in favor of Castles & Crusades, which ultimately led me back to B/X D&D. Best of luck on your return to "the roots."

    (I'd have to say that your analogy of 3.x as "a cumbersome corset" is spot on, BTW. It's exactly how I came to feel about the game.)

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Christopher - Thanks for your words, they're much appreciated. I thought nobody read this blog besides family and friends! ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous7:10 AM

    Welcome aboard to the (rules) lighter side of gaming.

    ReplyDelete

Labels

1e (15) 2e (11) 3.5e (18) 5e (3) ACKS (2) Ars Magica (2) art (1) AS&SH (1) ASE (1) BFRPG (1) Black Hack (1) Black Sun Deathcrawl (1) Blackmoor (14) Blades in the Dark (1) blogs (2) Board games (1) Books (17) BRP (1) Caballeros de Montevideo (2) Castle Amber (2) Castle Zagyg (9) Characters (46) Comics (2) Contest (13) Convention (8) D&D (7) d30 (1) DCC (28) Deadlands (1) Delta Green (1) Delving Deeper (1) dice tower (1) Dragon (4) Dragonlance (1) Drawings (6) Dresden Files (1) DSR (2) Dungeon (2) Dungeon Contest (8) Dungeon Lord (1) Dwimmermount (2) Dying Earth (1) Ennies (4) Era (2) FLAILSNAILS (16) Games (3) GAMMA World (1) GaryCon (2) GenCon (3) Google Wave (9) Google+ (37) Greyhawk (46) GURPS (4) Gygax (11) hangout (34) high level (1) HMS Apollyon (2) hobbit (1) Hollowpoint (3) Holmes (1) homebrew (1) Humor (2) Inspiration (1) Kalmatta (4) kids (3) Labyrinth Lord (28) Lamentations of the Flame Princess (6) Lego (1) Magic item (2) maps (2) Marvel (1) Maure Castle (6) Maze Rats (1) medieval (3) megadungeon (2) Metal Gods of Ur-Hadad (11) MicroLite74 (1) Middle Earth (1) Millenium's End (4) miniatures (3) MMO (1) module (1) movie (2) Mutants and Masterminds (1) Mythmere Games (1) Never Going Home (1) Nimue (3) NYNG (2) Oerth Journal (1) Old-School (15) OPDC (2) Oriental Adventures (3) OSE (1) OSR (18) OSRIC (6) Pathfinder (1) Patreon (1) playtest (1) quotes (4) Ramblings (16) Rifts (1) RPG (28) Rules (4) Rust (3) Saints & Sinners (1) sandbox (14) SS&SS (2) Star Wars (3) Swords and Wizardry (2) The Day After Ragnarok (1) TMNT (1) Transformers (1) Traveler (1) Ultima (4) Update (3) Wampus Country (2) Warhammer (2) WIAB (2) word count (2) World Cup (13) WoTC (6) zine (2)